- Mary Estrada's Pick: Burnt Offerings by Dipika Mukherjee
- Sean McKlusky's Pick: And So It Came to Pass by Holly Day
- Debi Orton's Pick: Cutter by Don Shea
- David Shapiro's Pick: This Is Why I Don't Keep a Journal by Jen Knox
- Vanitha Sankaran's Pick: Blue Cashmere by Deborah C. Strozier
- Didi Wood's Pick: Pi by Sandy Green